Best Reciprocating Saws – Complete Reviews With Comparison

Best Reciprocating Saws of 2018
Spread the love

When you're looking for something that is great for cutting in a versatile way, a reciprocating saw is the way to go.

These options are also quite powerful while still allowing you to hold and carry them rather comfortably.

There are also electric and battery options to choose from based on your needs.

Whether it's wood, pipe or other projects, these handy tools are worth having around.

This in-depth look at some top reciprocating saws and buying guide can help you with finding the best saw for you.

Just compare them carefully, consider what you need and you'll surely get the right tool.

Top 5 Reciprocating Saws Comparison Chart

BLACK+DECKER BDCR20B Reciprocating Saw

Milwaukee 6519-31 Reciprocating Sawzall

Ryobi P514 18V Cordless One

PORTER CABLE PCC670B Reciprocating Tigersaw

Ingersoll Rand 429 Heavy Duty Air Reciprocating Saw

Best Reciprocating Saw Reviews

1. BLACK + DECKER BDCR20B

If you're looking for an option that is very budget friendly, this device is reciprocating saw is worth a look.

Product Highlights

This little saw is an ideal choice for those who are looking for something they can use for smaller jobs on a budget. It does have a smaller cutting length at about 7/8 inches, but that's enough to handle things like rusted nails and sometimes smaller tree branches.

Furthermore, this is an option that uses a battery, which means there are no cords or gas to worry about. Just keep the battery charged and you can carry this tool off wherever you need to take it. On top of that, you'll be able to change out the blade without the need for extra tools.

What's to like about the BLACK + DECKER BDCR20B

The most notable aspect of this little saw is the price it comes at, which is quite a bit lower than other options out there. That makes it great for those who are on a tighter budget and still need some help in cutting. It also offers a decent amount of power for the price and size.

Some users have tried this out on things like rusted bolts that needed to be removed, but it can also come in handy in a variety of other situations. Because it's small and lightweight, it's also a pretty versatile little device that you can use just about anywhere you may need to.

What's not to like about the BLACK + DECKER BDCR20B

Some users may not appreciate that the battery and charger do need to be purchased separately. This can sometimes end up adding to the overall cost, so make sure to check out prices compared to other options and make sure you're choosing the option that's right for you.

In some other instances, users can find that there isn't enough power in the device for some of their more difficult tasks. It can also sometimes stop working without apparent cause. Consequently, it's a good idea to make sure you aren't overdoing it with this little tool.

PROS

  • check
    Plenty of power
  • check
    Works on rusted bolts
  • check
    Highly versatile

CONS

  • Battery and charger sold separately
  • Not enough power
  • Can stop working suddenly

2. Milwaukee 6519-31

If you want something with more power and don't mind a higher price to get it, this is an ideal choice.

Product Highlights

If you're looking for something highly compact, this is a fantastic option for you. It offers a power of about 3,000 strokes per minute, meaning you'll get plenty of power for most of your household tasks. It also offers a decent balance so you won't need to worry about losing track of what you're cutting.

In addition, there's a fantastic carrying case for when you need to take the saw with you on the go. You can be assured that the saw, any extra blades as well as accessories will be safe while you travel. All you'll need to do is make sure you have the ideal blades and you'll have everything you need.

What's to like about the Milwaukee 6519-31

Many users who try out this saw find that they have no trouble using it to handle most of their needs. It's a particularly powerful choice that also offers a lot of versatility. There is a reason it's called a Sawzall, because it can be used for a wide variety of things.

It's also a tool that is easy for most to use. Just insert a blade, plug it in and get to work. Just make sure the blade you have is ideal for whatever material you're working on. The good news is, you'll be able to change out blades without the use of any other tools, making it simple and easy.

What's not to like about the Milwaukee 6519-31

In some cases, users can find that the motor may suddenly stop working. This may be a result of overheating, so it's going to be important that you make sure that you're not making the device do more work than it can handle. ​

Others may find that the unit may arrive defective.  It's a good idea to ​try out the device soon after receiving it so that any potential problems can be fixed quickly. In some cases, users find that it may not be as durable as they expected.

PROS

  • check
    Versatile
  • check
    Powerful
  • check
    User-friendly

CONS

  • Motor can stop working
  • May not be sturdy enough
  • Some units may be defective

3. Ryobi P514

If you're looking for a middle-of-the-road option with a decent stroke speed and an affordable cost, this is a great choice.

Product Highlights

For those who want something reliable that comes at a decent cost, the Ryobi is a fantastic option. It's a lightweight, easy-to-use device that ensures you get the most from the saw without having to carry around too much weight, causing fatigue on your arms.

In addition, the handle is made to avoid vibration so you can stay comfortable while you work. You'll also be able to swap out the blades easily without the use of any extra tools, making replacing blades much easier. With 3,100 strokes per minute, it's hard to go wrong with this handy little saw.

What's to like about the Ryobi P514

Those who use this tool find it to be very versatile, and powerful enough to handle a variety of different tasks. Cutting things around the home or for a project will be much easier with this handy tool on your side. It's also a backwards-compatible option, allowing it to use other Ryobi-made batteries.

It also provides a fantastic warranty, allowing your investment to be protected during normal use for up to three years. Whenever you need cutting done, this is a great tool to use. It's lightweight enough to make the job easy and you'll be able to set it up with the perfect blades.

What's not to like about the Ryobi P514

In some cases, the unit can arrive in damaged condition so make sure to check it over as soon as you get it, so that any damage or other issues can be quickly addressed. In other cases, it can also be weaker than some of the other potential options out there, so make sure it's going to fit your needs.

There are also some instances in which there may be pieces missing, like blades or smaller accessories. This is another important reason for checking the device as soon as you get it. If you notice any issues, it's best to contact customer service as soon as possible.

PROS

  • check
    Very handy
  • check
    Makes cutting tasks a lot easier
  • check
    Includes a great warranty

CONS

  • Can arrive in damaged condition
  • May not be as powerful as other options
  • May be missing parts

4. Porter Cable PCC670B

This is a model you should be looking at if you want a decent amount of power at a price that won't break the bank.

Product Highlights

If high performance is important to you, then this is an ideal option. The Porter Cable saw allows for a 1-inch stroke length so it will be able to handle a bit more than some other options, placing it in right about the middle as far as length goes. It also uses a 20V battery so you can use it just about anywhere.

Due to the compact design, this is an easy tool to take just about anywhere, and you'll easily be able to change out the blade without any other tools. Due to the available power, you'll also be able to handle more aggressive cutting needs than some of the other models will allow.

What's to like about the Porter Cable PCC670B

More and more, customers appreciate the design of power tools that use batteries rather than cords or gas. It allows for more portability, meaning you can carry it around wherever you need it without worry for a plugin or affecting the environment with carbon-laden fumes.

In addition to the lightweight portability, this is also an option that is quite powerful. You won't need to worry about it having too much trouble cutting through surfaces as long as you make sure the thickness fits the stroke length that the saw is able to handle.

What's not to like about the Porter Cable PCC670B

In some cases, there can be some issues with this saw. Just like any other product, not all units are going to be built perfectly. One issue that can occur is overheating, so try to keep an eye on the saw while it's working to avoid causing the motor too much of an issue.

Others may find that the saw can run pretty loudly, which can become a problem for those with sensitive hearing. It is a good idea to make sure you have hearing protection when using tools like these in general. The vibration on this device can also be more intense than some others out there.

PROS

  • check
    Freedom from cords
  • check
    Very powerful
  • check
    Lightweight

CONS

  • May overheat
  • Intense vibrations
  • ​Runs louder than others

5. Ingersoll Rand 429

For those who like something simple and effective, this is a great tool to use.

Product Highlights

For your smaller jobs, the Ingersoll Rand saw may be the perfect choice. It offers a smaller stroke length of about an inch, meaning it may not be able to get through your thicker things as easily. However, when appropriately used this little tool can be quite the powerhouse.

Furthermore, it works decently on both curved and flat surfaces, making it a pretty versatile tool. On top of that, customers are unlikely to complain about the 10,000 strokes per minute. It's also made to keep vibrations reduced so that you can remain comfortable as you're working.

What's to like about the Ingersoll Rand 429

For most, this is an option that is more budget friendly than some of the others out there. This makes it great when you need something quick and don't want to spend too much. It's also a powerful machine that will be able to handle a wide variety of tasks, providing a lot of value.

Another factor customers appreciate is the ability of this saw to provide clean cuts. That not only makes the job easier, but it leaves your work looking much more professional. It often requires less touching up to look decent, and can make your job a whole lot easier.

What's not to like about the Ingersoll Rand 429

Not all users have had the best experience while trying out this saw. Some have found that it may not be ideal for automotive work. ​And some have found that the blades can be more difficult to take out than with other options.

Some users may find that no instructions for use are included, which can be frustrating for those who are new to the tool. Breakage can sometimes occur during use. Make sure to try it out carefully before really getting down to business.

PROS

  • check
    Powerful
  • check
    Budget friendly
  • check
    Provides clean cuts

CONS

  • Blades can be difficult to change
  • Not the best for automotive work
  • May not include instructions

BUYER'S GUIDE

When you're shopping for the perfect reciprocating saw, it's wise to consider the brand, type of blades and materials you use, the power source, the voltage, saw type and whether it's corded or cordless.

Brand

Not all saw brands are going to be equal. There will of course be some big-name brands that you'll recognize, as well as smaller brands that you may not have seen before, and everything in between. It can help to look into the brands themselves to get a good idea of the quality provided by each one, as well as how they handle warranties and other similar concerns.

Type

You'll also want to think about the type of material you want to cut, and the type of blade you want to use. This can include the stroke length available on the device, depending on how thick the material is that you want to cut. Some are also more likely to work better on wood, while other blades are better for metal and harder surfaces.

Power Source

Consider where you'll want to use the saw, as this can play a huge part in what kind of power source you need. If you'll be near an outlet, then an electric option may be just fine. Otherwise, a battery option may be better suited. If you'd prefer something with more power and aren't concerned about the effect on the environment, you can also decide to go with a gas reciprocating saw.

Voltage

Reciprocating saws that use a battery as their source of power can include batteries of varying voltage levels. Consequently, it's important to have an understanding of what that voltage is going to mean for your power and battery life, so that you can choose the right one. In some cases, it can be a good idea to also grab a backup battery if you have longer jobs to get through.

Saw Type

There can be a decent number of different saw types out there to choose from, including power source options, stroke lengths, brands, sizes and blade types. Keep in mind that different blade types can work better on different materials. Overall, it's wise to know what you need before you start shopping so that you can find the tool that will work best.

Corded or Cordless

Some may have difficulty choosing between a cordless or corded option. There are benefits and downfalls to both. A corded option can provide unlimited power, but it does mean dragging around a cord that can get in the way, be cut or cause other issues. Meanwhile, a cordless option offers more freedom but can run out of power in the middle of a job.

Reciprocating Saw F.A.Q.

How to use a reciprocating saw?

Start by making sure you have all the tools, accessories and safety gear you'll need. Insert your chosen blade carefully, making sure it's locked into position. Then make sure to use the speed that works best for you. Start slowly if you aren't sure. Keep both hands on the device at all times for full control, and see-saw the blade when needed if you're working on something thicker.

Using a reciprocating saw for cutting wood?

To begin with, you'll want to make sure you have the right kind of blade for the task, and that your saw can handle the thickness of the wood you're cutting. If you're trying to cut larger chunks of wood, a chainsaw may be the more ideal tool, but with enough patience it can be done. Just make sure to handle the blade steadily and carefully as you would with any other material.

How to cut a straight line with a reciprocating saw

One of the most important aspects is making sure that whatever you're cutting is steady. It may require some measuring and marking, but find the line you want to cut into the material and keep the saw steady as you do so, allowing for a straighter cut.

Can I use a reciprocating saw to prune trees?

Yes, you can. A reciprocating saw is a relatively versatile tool that can handle pruning trees. However, using a pruning blade on your saw will allow you to get better results than a standard blade. Also make sure that your blade length will work well for the thickness of the branches.

What does a reciprocating saw do?

A reciprocating saw can do a multitude of different things. You can use it for cutting through wood, metal, and other materials. It can also be used for pruning plants. Simply put, there is a very good reason why this kind of tool is often referred to as a “sawzall.”

FINAL VERDICT

The top saw choice in this list is the Porter Cable PCC670B. This is a device that has received a lot of positive reviews, offers a decent amount of power and comes at an affordable price. It also includes a 3-year warranty that is very useful in ensuring your investment is safe if problems should occur.

If that doesn't seem like your best choice, the other saws in this list aren't far behind. There are options that are more budget friendly, more powerful and better suited to whatever the task is you need to complete. Make sure you check them all out and choose the one that best suits your needs.

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below

Leave a Reply: